Back to Basics: Multiplication is NOT the Inverse of Division!

Multiplication symbolI often hear the mantra, “Multiplication is the inverse of division.”Division symbol

The bottom line: it’s wrong. And, since it does cause confusion for some, it’s a good idea to stop saying it. Basically, it is an oversimplification. Here’s what is really true: If you pick a nonzero number N, then multiplication by N is the inverse of division by N.

Perhaps you’re thinking, “Is this distinction really so important? It seems so nit-picky.”

The problem is that because of this mantra, I’ve seen students get into conceptual difficulties later when they encounter inverse functions. Because of the mantra, they try to regard multiplication and division as inverses to each other, when, technically, they aren’t.

When we say that an operation is the inverse of another, we mean that the operation undoes whatever the other operation does. Multiplication takes two numbers and returns a single number, their product. To invert this, we would have to start with a single number (the product) and return the original two factors. But we can write every number as a product in an infinitude of different ways. Technically, therefore, multiplication does not even have an inverse.

Even more basic, if you have a function f : S \to T, then its inverse function, assuming it exists, would be a map from T to S. We can think of multiplication as a function from R \times R to R. If multiplication had an inverse, that inverse would have to map from R to R \times R. But division doesn’t map from R to R \times R.  Instead, division also takes two numbers (one of which must not be zero) and returns a single number: their quotient. (Here, R is the set of real numbers.)

On the other hand, if you fix a nonzero number N, then multiplication by N is inverted by division by N. In functional notation, the functions f(x) = Nx and g(x) = x/N are inverse to each other: Both f(g(x)) = x and g(f(x))=x.

There’s a more conceptual reason why we should stamp out the mantra: Multiplication and division are actually two ways to look at the same thing. They are like two different views of the same elephant. Indeed, if you don’t like division, you don’t have to use it because you can always use multiplication instead. And, except for multiplication by zero, the same is true the other way around. For example, if you’d rather not divide by 5, you can always multiply by 0.2 instead.

Let’s make the point clear with a visual image. Because division by zero is undefined, let’s restrict our attention to positive numbers only. We can represent multiplication in the first quadrant of the plane by setting the temperature of each point to the product of its coordinates. We represent division analogously. Now let’s twist this representation slightly by working on a piece of semi-log graph paper instead of the first quadrant.  See below.

Multiplication and Division on semi-log paper

Color indicates temperature. In one rectangle, temperature is given by the product xy. In the other, temperature is given by the quotient x/y.

Does one rectangle look like an exact mirror image of the other? It should, because they are! Multiplication and division are just two ways to look at the same thing.

Hopefully, you’ll never carelessly say “multiplication is the inverse of division” again.

Advertisements

About girlsangle

We're a math club for girls.
This entry was posted in math, Math Education and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Back to Basics: Multiplication is NOT the Inverse of Division!

  1. Dennis says:

    Well, I was convinced until the heat map. If the division heat map was inverted vertically wouldn’t it look exactly the same as the multiplication map?

  2. Brad says:

    That was very illuminating, thank you.

  3. kandpalap says:

    In the same line of thought, even addition and subtraction are not inverse operation because subtraction doesn’t map from R to R+R

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s